This is a great local spot! I got the Fried Fisherman's Platter and a bowl of New England Clam Chowder. Portion size was great and everything was properly cooked. The best parts were the homemade cocktail and tartar sauce, tender juicy fish, and fries that were perfectly crispy yet still soft in the center.

Love the Cull House! Great seafood, great service, great atmosphere. Close to the Fire Island ferries and the water, catches a little breeze if you're sitting outside on a nice evening. Been coming here for 30 years, always great. Good craft beer selection. Clams casino, yumm.

This place felt very cozy and has a lot of personality! Highly recommend it for tasting the local seafood on Long Island. The calamari with balsamic reduction was a fun, savory twist. The oysters had two different sauces you can drizzle on them. We had the lobster clam bake which was delicious! You can't really go wrong ordering anything on the menu here.

We stopped for dinner after a day on fire island. The food was great, and so was the service. The mussels may have been the best I've ever had, and I am a big fan of mussels. The broiled bay scallobs were also great, so fresh. And the drink I had, OMG. Toasted coconut martini!!

The Cull House catered a lobster bake for our son's Fire Island engagement party this weekend. The food arrived on Fire Island still hot and all delicious. The servers were so friendly that we hated to have them leave the party at the end of the night. Thanks to everyone at the Cull House for a memorable event!