Our Menu
GF - Gluten free
Appetizers
Shrimp Cocktail (5) (GF)
$12.00
Gluten friendly
Baked Clams
$15.00
4 chopped and stuffed local cherrystones with bacon
Fried Calamari
$18.00
Marinara sauce
Fried Calamari with Hot Cherry Pepper Rings
$18.00
Balsamic reduction
Clams Casino (6) (GF)
$15.00
Gluten friendly: Littleneck clams, broiled with butter, garlic, peppers & bacon
Prince Edward Island Mussels (GF)
$20.00
Gluten Friendly: Luciano-garlic, butter & white wine sauce
Steamed Little Neck Clams (12) (GF)
$18.00
Gluten friendly: Dozen clams luciano - garlic butter & white wine sauce
Fried Shrimp (5)
$15.00
Tartar sauce
Jumbo Buffalo Chicken Wings (7)
$15.00
Bleu cheese dressing, celery & carrot sticks mild, medium or hot
Chicken Fingers (4)
$12.00
Honey mustard dipping sauce or buffalo style
Mozzarella Sticks (7)
$12.00
Garlic Bread
$6.00
Oysters Rockefeller (4) (GF)
$18.00
Gluten friendly: chopped spinach, shallots, anisette cream
Bavarian Pretzel
$14.00
served with beer cheese
Loaded Tater Tots
$14.00
dressed in cheese sauce & bacon bits
Soups & Salads
New England Clam Chowder
$10.00
Lobster Bisque
$12.00
Manhattan Clam Chowder (GF)
$9.00
Gluten friendly
Soup of the Day
MP
The Wedge (GF)
$12.00/+
Gluten friendly: Iceberg, applewood smoked bacon, cherry tomato, bleu cheese crumbles, parmesan peppercorn dressing • Shrimp $12.00 | Chicken $12.00 | Tuna $17.00 | Salmon $17.00 | Lobster Meat MP
Classic Caesar Salad
$11.00/+
Hearts of romaine lettuce, shaved parmesan, garlic crouton & Caesar dressing • Shrimp $12.00 | Chicken $12.00 | Tuna $17.00 | Salmon $17.00 | Lobster Meat MP
The Cull Salad (GF)
$11.00/+
Gluten friendly: mesclun greens, candied walnuts, goat cheese, raspberry vinaigrette • Shrimp $12.00 | Chicken $12.00 | Tuna $17.00 | Salmon $17.00 | Lobster Meat MP
Raw Bar
Cold Combo *(raw) (GF)
$21.00
Gluten friendly: 3 oysters, 4 clams, 2 shrimp
Seafood Tower for Two * (GF)
$49.00
Gluten friendly: Chilled 1/2 lobster, 4 shrimp, 4 oysters, 4 clams
Seafood Tower for Four * (GF)
$89.00
Gluten friendly: Chilled whole lobster, 8 shrimp, 8 oysters, 8 clams
Dozen Clams on the Half Shell * (raw) (GF)
$21.00
Gluten friendly
Dozen Oysters on the Half Shell * (raw) (GF)
$30.00
Gluten friendly
Specialties
served with rice and vegetable
Broiled Fisherman's Platter
$34.00
Shrimp, bay scallops, crab cake, baked clam, filet
Sesame Crusted Yellowfin Tuna * (GF)
$29.00
Gluten Friendly: Vietnamese dipping sauce, cooked to your liking
Cedar Plank Whiskey Salmon
$28.00
Roasted cedar plank salmon, Kentucky bourbon glaze
Crabmeat Stuffed Jumbo Shrimp (5)
$29.00
Beurre blanc, parsely crumb
Long Island Crab Cakes (3)
$30.00
Jumbo cakes, claw meat, lemon mayo bread crumb, smoked paprika aioli
Baked & Broiled Seafood Combo (GF)
$35.00
Gluten Friendly: 2 oysters rockefeller, 3 clams casino, 3 shrimp, bay scallops, filet
Broiled Bay Scallops (GF)
$30.00
Gluten Friendly: parsley crumb
Fried Seafood
Includes French fries
Fried Fishermans Platter
$33.00
Shrimp, bay scallops, clam strips, filet
Fish & Chips
$25.00
beer battered cod, steak fries, served with cole slaw
Fried Shrimp & Bay Scallops Combo
$28.00
Fried Bay Scallops
$30.00
Fried Shrimp
$27.00
Fried Clams
$27.00
Fried or Broiled Fish Sandwich
$23.00
Gluten Friendly Available: fish of the day, chipotle mayo, on a brioche roll
Cull House Lobster Clam Bake
Cull House Lobster Clam Bake (GF)
MP
steamed 11⁄4 lb lobster, littleneck clams, P.E.I. mussels, sausage, potato wedges, corn on the cob (seasonal), scampi butter sauce | 1 1/2 lb. lobsters add $10.00
Lobsters
Call for larger lobster 2-5 lbs GF (1 day notice please | $25 per lobster non-refundable deposit)
Lobster Roll
MP
Classic Maine or Connecticut-style toasted garlic brioche roll served with french fries
Lobster Roll Supreme
1/2LB Maine lobster claw & tail meat served on a garlic brioche roll, served with french fries
1 1/4 Lb. Steamed (GF)
MP
served with baked potato and a vegetable
1 1/2- 1 3/4 lb Steamed (GF)
MP
served with baked potato and a vegetable
Lobster Clam Bake (GF)
$52.00/+
Gluten Friendly: 1 1/4lb Lobster, littleneck clams, P.E.I. Mussels, sausage, potato wedges, corn on the cob (seasonal), scampi butter sauce | Upgrade to a 1 1/2LB lobster +$10
Surf & Turf (GF)
Gluten Friendly: 12oz Waygu Ribeye & 6oz Lobster Tail, served with baked potato and a vegetable
Twin 6oz Lobster Tails (GF)
Gluten Friendly: served with baked potato and a vegetable
Lobster Party Bake
Fully cooked - take out or delivery | Call 24 hours in advance | Serves 12-15 people
Lobster Party Bake
$595.00
12 - 11⁄4 lb steamed Maine lobsters, 4 dozen steamed littleneck clams Luciano, 5 pounds steamed pei mussels, 3 pounds grilled sweet sausage, dozen ears corn, 3 pounds steak fries, condiments
1-1/4lb Lobster
$25.00
Steamed Clams (1oz)
$15.00
Grilled Sausage (1lb)
$14.00
Tacos
served with french fries
3 Baja Cod Tacos
$24.00
Beer battered cod, guacamole, citrus slaw, baja sauce
3 Blackened Shrimp or Chicken Tacos (GF)
$24.00
Gluten Friendly: corn tortilla, lettuce, cheese, guacamole, pico de gallo
Pasta
Includes a garden salad. Gluten-friendly pasta available for $3.00 extra
Frutti di Mare (GFA)
$34.00
Shrimp, mussels, bay scallops, littleneck clams, cod, tomato seafood broth over linguini | GFA $3
Seafood Rigatoni Ala Vodka (GFA)
$27.00
Shrimp, scallops | GFA $3
Linguini with White Clam Sauce (GFA)
$26.00/+
Whole & chopped clams, garlic, white wine | Add shrimp $32.00 | GFA $3
Classic Shrimp Scampi (GFA)
$27.00
garlic butter, lemon, white wine sauce over linguini | GFA $3
Meats
12oz Waygu Ribeye* (GF)
$65.00
Gluten Friendly: garlic butter - served with a vegetable and baked potato
Waygu Hamburger* (GFA+2)
$22.00
brioche roll— cooked to your liking served with french fries • Add cheese $1.00 | Add bacon $2.00 | Add Lobster Meat MP - GFA +2
Grilled or Fried Chicken Sandwich (GFA+2)
$22.00
Chicken breast, applewood smoked bacon, swiss cheese, lettuce, tomato, chipotle mayo, on a brioche roll, served with french fries - GFA +2
Chicken Picatta (GF)
$27.00
Gluten Friendly: chicken breast, lemon, wine, capers, artichokes - served with a vegetable and baked potato
Desserts
Salted Caramel Espresso Bars
$5.00
Espresso ganache, salted caramel, graham crust
Creme Brûlée
$5.00
Rich custard base topped with caramelized sugar
Chocolate Mousse
$5.00
Whipped cream, chocolate chips
Apple Crisp
$5.00
Fuji apples baked with brown sugar, cinnamon and streusel topping-served warm | Ala mode $1.50
Brownie Sundae
$7.00
Warm, ala mode with chocolate sauce and whipped cream
Bavarian Cream Churro
$5.00
2 fried bavarian cream churros, caramel, chocolate syrup, cinnamon sugar | Ala mode $1.50
Adult Desserts
Shanky's Whip Float
$15.00
Shanky's Whipped Bourbon, rootbeer, vanilla ice cream, whip cream
Tiramisu Milkshake
$15.00
Tito's Handmade Vodka, Irish Cream, Kahlúa, espresso, chocolate syrup, whipped cream
Mudslide
$15.00
Tito's Handmade Vodka, Kahlúa, Irish Cream, vanilla Iie cream, whipped cream, chocolate chips
Kids Meal
Your choice- served with a soft drink
1/4 Lb Hamburger On A Toasted Bun
$12.00
With fries
Penne Marinara
$12.00
Golden Fried Chicken Fingers
$12.00
With fries
Grilled Cheese
$12.00
With fries
Mac N Cheese
$12.00
Daily 12 pm - 3:30 pm • Private parties for 15-60 people, with tip included, starting at 30$ per person. Ask to speak with Johnny.
Menu
Add a cup of soup to specials for only +$6.00 |
Lobster Roll Lunacy
$24.00
Eat-in only | One per guest |
Autumn Spinach Salad - GF
$14.00
spinach salad, almonds, granny smith apples, diced beets, brie cheese & balsamic vinaigrette
California Veggie Burger
$16.00
lettuce, tomato, vegenaise & pretzel roll - served with french fries
Fried Oyster Po'Boy
$18.00
fried oysters, spicy slaw, romaine, tomatoes, spicy aioli on french bread - served with french fries
Fish & Chips
$15.00
served with coleslaw
Creamy Skillet Chicken - GF
$20.00
chicken breast, baby spinach, mushrooms, bell peppers, onions, parmesan cheese & cream
Shrimp Caesar Wrap
$18.00
blackened shrimp, romaine lettuce, shaved parmesan cheese & spinach flour wrap
Crab Cake Sandwich
$18.00
mesclun greens, tomato, spicy aioli & pretzel roll - served with french fries
November 20-26
COCKTAIL
Pumpkin Martini
$15.00
vanilla vodka, pumpkin liquor, Irish cream liquor, finished with cinnamon
SOUP
Sweet Potato Bisque - GF
$10.00
creamy sweet potato puree with a touch of cinnamon
APPETIZER
Cajun Shrimp Tostones - GF
$15.00
crispy plantain tostones topped with mango salsa, guacamole, Monterrey jack cheese and cilantro aioli
ENTREE
Moriches Bay Scallops
$46.00
broiled and sauteed - GF or fried - served with a vegetable & rice
Pan Seared Rainbow Trout- GF
$28.00
with quinoa rice pilaf & tomato-caper sauce - served with a vegetable
Seafood Shepherds Pie - GF
$36.00
shrimp, scallops, Maine lobster meat, hard boiled eggs, peas, carrots, potatoes, and seafood cream, asiago cheese, baked with whipped potato topping
Blackened Swordfish Tacos - GF
$25.00
corn tortillas filled with blackened swordfish, pineapple salsa, and guacamole - served with french fries
CRAFT BEER SPECIALS
Standard Cider GF-Hudson North, NY
$8.00/12oz
GF | crisp, full bodied, from your local farm stand 16oz can - 5% ABV
Deep Ascent Pale Ale - St. James, NY
$10.00/16oz.
brewed w/ 130 year old yeast found in bottles of beer from 1889 shipwreck Oregon off of L.I. - 7.0% ABV
Focal Banger IPA - Alchemist, VT
$10.00/16oz.
citra & mosaic hops, British malts - 7% ABV
Biere des Chevaliers - St. James, NY
$10.00/16 oz.
Belgium style dubbel, deep reddish - 7.0% ABV
Endless Life Helles - Brooklyn, NY
$10.00/16oz.
made for Paramount Club NYC 16oz. can - 5% ABV
Heady Topper DIPA - Alchemist, VT
$10.00/16oz.
Voted #1 IPA in the country - 8.0% ABV
Modelo Especial - Mexico
$5.00/12oz.
pilsner-style lager - 4.4% ABV
Hazy IPNA - Lagunitas, CA
$8.00/12oz.
hoppy, passionfruit - 0.0% ABV
Carmel Apple Cider - GF - Hudson North Co., NY
$10.00/16oz.
NY apples w/ sweet caramel - 5% ABV
Duvel Tripel Hop Citra IPA - Belgium
$10.00/330ml. btl
dry hopped w/ citra hops - 9.5% ABV
• GF/GFA - Gluten Friendly
• 4 Course Dinner $65.00 per person
• Soup or Salad, Appetizer, Entree, & Dessert
• Make Your Reservations Now: 631 - 563 - 1546
• $20.00 per person credit card hold is required. Cancellations made after 12/29 will result in the card on file being charged
Soup or Salad
New England Clam Chowder
Manhattan Clam Chowder (GF)
Lobster Bisque
Caesar Salad
Arugula Salad
Caramelized fuji apples, fried goat cheese, pine nuts & apple vinaigrette
Frisee Caprese Salad (GF)
Heirloom cherry tomatoes, fresh mozzarella, basil & Italian vinaigrette
Appetizers
Honey Calamari
Toasted sesame seeds, scallions
Baked Clams
Shrimp Tempura
Sweet Thai chili sauce
*1/2 Dozen Tall Mutha Shucker Oysters (GF)
+$5.00
German Oysters (GF)
Sauerkraut, prosciutto, asiago cheese & chives
Coquille Saint Jacques (GF)
Bay scallops, mayo and Montrrey jack cheesee
Entrees
Broiled Fisherman's Platter
Shrimp, bay scallops, crab cake, baked clams & fillet- served with rice & vegetable
Fried Fisherman's Platter
Shrimp, bay scallops, filet, clam strips - served with French fries
Pan Seared Moriches Bay Scallops (GF)
White truffle risotto - served with a vegetable | +$15.00
Sesame Crusted Yellowfin Tuna (GF)
Vietnamese dipping sauce - served with rice & a vegetable
Faroe Island Salmon
Kentucky bourbon glaze on a cedar plank - served with rice & a vegetable
Pan Fried Parmesan Crusted Pork Chops
Caramelized white onions, creamy tomato fondue, baked potato and a vegetable
Fried Shrimp and Bay Scallops
Served with French fries
Pan Seared Chilean Sea Bass (GF)
Sweet potato puree, broccolini & red wine demi-glace | +$5.00
Grilled 10oz Wagyu New York Strip (GF)
Mashed potatoes, haricot verts & mushroom brandy peppercorn sauce | +$15.00
Add 6oz Lobster Tail +$10.00
Add 6oz Lobster Tail +$10.00
Lobster Mac & Cheese (GFA)
Maine lobster meat, cheddar cheese, scallions & bowtie pasta | +$5.00
6oz Twin Lobster Tails (GF)
Served with baked potato and a vegetable | +$5.00